The extra speakers myth was debunked in the 80's by the Boston Audion Society with none other than Linn's Ivor. Look it up.
Multiple subs are for more even bass throughout the room not accurate bass at the LP. Read Toole's book.
PSA: Short Unused Speakers and Subs in the Listening Room
I think most people know this, but it’s important to electrically short speakers and/or subwoofers in the listening room that aren’t being used. This can be accomplished by connecting the terminals together with a spare speaker cable or jumpers.
I had a pair of passive, sealed subwoofers I didn’t have hooked up in the listening room. I could tap on the subwoofer cone and the room would energize with bass at the resonance frequency of the subwoofer. When I shorted the terminals with a copper wire and tapped on the cone, there was silence. It was quite remarkable actually.
Has anyone else experienced this? One question I have is if I should short a subwoofer that is not in any sort of box or enclosure. When I tap on it, it doesn’t seem to energize the room with sound.