I've had great experiences with Discogs. In the cases of the two records I received that weren't as described, the sellers quickly refunded my money and didn't even ask for the record back. That said, Dusty Groove out of Chicago is my go to place for new and great used records. They list new arrivals which is great. Shipping is super fast. Love them. My daughter lives close by so I always hit the shop when we visit.
http://https//www.dustygroove.com
http://https//www.dustygroove.com