Top ten American composers/songwriters


Foster
Sousa
Joplin
Gershwin 
Copland
Jimmie Rodgers
Ellington
Richard Rodgers
Dylan
Porter

I constantly revisit this topic listening and reading. Thoughts?

jpwarren58
To say Copland's music doesn't capture the American spirit...he incorporates our folk music, energy level, optimism.  And nothing against Barber. Just very hard to make choices. Some day someone will. The big question will be them referencing this thread. Lol. 

Oops, Nick Lowe, like Tillbrook & Difford, is English. He was married to Carlene Carter for awhile (who hasn't been?), if that counts.

By the way, Brian Wilson's favorite American (and perhaps universal) composer is Gershwin. He recorded a tribute album to him, which I haven't gotten up the nerve to listen to.

It IS "hard to make choices" when considering two great talents such as Barber and Copland. However, there is no doubt in my mind that Samuel Barber was the greater of the two; and not by a little. The level of sophistication of his compositions and mastery of orchestration were on an entirely different level; not to mention a wider scope encompassing not just orchestral music, but opera and choral music as well.

I suppose an argument can be made that he was the "more American" (and not simply "American") of the two; if that is the subjective standard to be used . However, by that standard I would say that the music of Leonard Bernstein encompasses all that Copland’s did and more; by incorporating two quintessentially American genres, Jazz and Musical Theater.