Sounds to me like you have a mismatch in your preamp section. If you have the phono stage connected to the Blueberry's phono inputs, you are going to have problems. The interconnects from your phonostage should be connected to an auxilary input on the Blueberry. Try that, and make sure you have the phono stage set up properly for the cartridge you are using, and you should be fine.
Good luck,
Dan
Good luck,
Dan