Mike,
What a great thread! Thanks for starting it. I hope you will assemble a summary list. I don’t know much but hope you all don’t mind if I add some thoughts. If anyone would like to steer me straight on any of this please post. I really want to know more on the subject.
Anyway, seems like there are two questions here: first, favorite and disliked for whatever musical or record-related reason, and; second, which labels are, quality wise, reliable and which are not: and, which are just bound to be bad. The first involves taste along with quality. The second not so much.
Here is most of what I know from my own records:
ECM
My favorite label. I love this music and I can (nearly always) count on record quality. I have hundreds and I can only think of one that disappointed- it’s just ok. Was supposed to be special on 180 gm but doesn’t sound very good.
Ume
Resonance Records
Sintra
Jazz on the above labels is fantastic.
For classical I have found that the following deliver consistently good experience:
Berliner Philharmoniker (The Orchestra’s own label)
Accentus Music
hyperion
Lyrita
Old RCA Victor (Red Labels/Seal)
Old London Records
The Classics Record Library
Sony Classical
Again, YMMV. I don’t know a lot about classical record labels but really want to learn more.
Then, I have fancy “Audiophile” type records from the following and can’t say anything but good about all of them.
Impex
Analogue Productions
Acoustic Sounds
Tone Poet
MA Recordings
Intervention
ORG (Original Recordings Group)
ORG (the other ORG)
Chesky Records
The MA and Chesky that I have are truly spectacular. Some of the other fancy expensive labels that are supposed to be special have been hit and miss for me. The handful of Mofi’s that I have are mostly great.
Of the relatively larger operation labels, I feel like I can count of these:
Reprise
Sony Legacy
Chrysallis
Friday Music
Rhino Records
Chrysallis is a favorite I guess because of their catalogue and I generally really like the way they sound.
Here are a few of my favorite smaller, or what’s called independent, and other labels (some have already been mentioned of course).
Nettwerk
Sugar Hill Records
Yep Rock Records
Rounder Records
Sub-Pop
Nonesuch
Blue Corn
Horton Records
37d03d
Craft Recordings
Dualtone
Glassnote
Western Vinyl
Vinyl Me Please
Concord
Dead Oceans
Lifesong
Kirshner (probably defunct?)
New West is also a favorite of mine. I have a large handful of newer stuff from them and it’s all very good or great. Maybe they used to have problems but this has not been my experience.
I get terrific reissues from:
Run Out Groove
Back on Black
My categorical dislikes are few:
Geffin Records has been mostly disappointing, particularly because he had a couple of my favorite artists under contract. No more fortunately.
Jazz Wax Records and their ilk. Shady operators based in Europe take CD’s of music in the open domain and get records pressed in Russia or in other dark recesses of Eastern Europe. They always sound horrible. I learned the hard way but apparently the word has been out.
And, of the love hate variety:
Along with Music on Vinyl and Mofi,
I have learned that many records put out by Four Men With Beards (and the other subsidiaries of Runt records in San Francisco) are of atrocious quality but one that I have is great so do the research before purchase.
I have found the same to be true of Atco.
I mention these last two because they do have some temptingly great titles. I just need to remember to watch out.
Finally, regarding manufacturing, I have learned to avoid anything pressed at United in Texas.
Thanks again for the thread and all the contribution to it.