What phono preamp are you using?

Herron VTPH-2A
Parasound JC3 Jr.
Vincent PHO-8 (as emergency backup)

No Soundsmith cart., unfortunately.   Ortofon Quintet on VPI Scout T/T.

-Jim

Fosgate Signature V2 with  Audio Technica Art-9

I am using a rogue magnum stealth and an original rega ios and both are dead quiet even on an ultra low output mc cartridge so i can say that they are very good options. Also the parasound jc3+ would be a good choice and will grow with your table and system. The first two mentioned are also very quiet even on +100 decibel speakers which is very important for lovers of tube amplifiers.

I went from a Parasound JC3 Jr., to Herron VTPH-2A, to PS Audio Stellar. With a 1200G and Ortofon Quintet Black.  Surprisingly to me, the Herron and PS Audio were basically a toss-up.  The Stellar is dead quite and sounds great.

"Fosgate Signature V2 with Audio Technica Art-9"

Same setup as melm. Both(Foz out of production) excellent pieces. Presently have a Kiseki Blue thru the Foz.

Soundsmith is a great choice. Get the most you can afford. You will have the ability to send it back when it needs a tune up. Used a $399 entry level  Soundsmith Otello. It's "the best" in case of emergency, break glass-back up cart I've heard so far.