That cash you are getting back is built in, pre-paid, and I personally would not ever rely on CC protection as a reason to use a CC, but I do agree with you about carrying a CC balance. I used to agree that cards can be a tool, but not any more. This is not to be confused with a debit card which I find to be a much more useful tool. Since the banking melt-down CCs are looked at by the banks as a way to load up fees, and they have done a great job of it before the new regulations kick in to stop them. Next up on the chopping block will be free checking, and probably interest-bearing checking, as these are not funds the banks can count on as part of their lending reserves.