09-18-12: CsontosAs I see it, the conclusion stated in your first sentence can only be read into his posts with respect to off-axis listening, for which the Carver Sonic Hologram essentially doesn't work. My take on the rest of his comments is reflected in my previous post, which amounts primarily to an opinion that his findings should not be expected to have broad applicability. Not sure what else there is to say.
Al, he's stating for all intents and purposes, that he's experiencing a far higher degree of holography than you did with your Carver!! I can't believe you're willing to reconcile this to personal individual experience. Reminds me of the seventies when a bunch of brand names attempted to pass themselves off as high end by producing spuriously favorable specs. What's up? Diplomacy does have a down side. Namely public perception.
Regards,
-- Al