Wow I just read page #48 and have not read page #49!
I step out for a little while and Holy Smokes lots of action!
Just at the part about John K. (sorry if I say something in page #49!)
"If I mod'ed it it must be better". (posted by Johnk)
That is EXACTLY how this thread started! I swapped out one whole network (one speaker) and left the other original.
I (like most) was quite happy with my handy work and I brought my wife down for a listen as an unbiased opinion. She was totally impressed! She thought the difference was huge from the two networks and said "you must really be thrilled to get such an improvement"? (not having done any of this before)
The problem was she was picking the vintage foil in oil network NOT the new poly caps!...
I knew at that moment things were not going to be clear money was going to be spent and sometimes wasted and this was going to have to be wrote off as interesting experiment.
I knew I was going to have to listen lots.
Some did not like the mod one speaker listen for a long time if good do the mod to the other carry on method but as JohnK mentioned you can not test from memory.
In time (and after some failures) I got better at what would work and gained some understanding. As one's understanding grows so does the frustration with most new gear... (but I do know why high end parts are not used)
This thread is about people's opinions for the most part with nothing sell.
I have said (and is deserved) a lot of good about Duelund parts. Oddly enough though I am one who has had a Duelund CAST cap leak and in reality Duelund is the ONLY capacitor I have had fail.
Now Duelund will give a refund which leaves me with one CAST at the value... (not a common value)
I am using the store credit for some Jupiter caps, quite likely. I have to just see if they fit. My pace of alterations has slowed in recent years. Am I upset? No! I am not even looking at new gear which is a good thing! (very happy)
Johnk has been on this thread for a long time and has made some valid points but I believe he is a horn speaker builder.
I have said on here many times I would not want to build speakers with Duelund parts and try and make money!
Do the parts matter? YES! Would I want to use them build speakers to make money? NO!
I step out for a little while and Holy Smokes lots of action!
Just at the part about John K. (sorry if I say something in page #49!)
"If I mod'ed it it must be better". (posted by Johnk)
That is EXACTLY how this thread started! I swapped out one whole network (one speaker) and left the other original.
I (like most) was quite happy with my handy work and I brought my wife down for a listen as an unbiased opinion. She was totally impressed! She thought the difference was huge from the two networks and said "you must really be thrilled to get such an improvement"? (not having done any of this before)
The problem was she was picking the vintage foil in oil network NOT the new poly caps!...
I knew at that moment things were not going to be clear money was going to be spent and sometimes wasted and this was going to have to be wrote off as interesting experiment.
I knew I was going to have to listen lots.
Some did not like the mod one speaker listen for a long time if good do the mod to the other carry on method but as JohnK mentioned you can not test from memory.
In time (and after some failures) I got better at what would work and gained some understanding. As one's understanding grows so does the frustration with most new gear... (but I do know why high end parts are not used)
This thread is about people's opinions for the most part with nothing sell.
I have said (and is deserved) a lot of good about Duelund parts. Oddly enough though I am one who has had a Duelund CAST cap leak and in reality Duelund is the ONLY capacitor I have had fail.
Now Duelund will give a refund which leaves me with one CAST at the value... (not a common value)
I am using the store credit for some Jupiter caps, quite likely. I have to just see if they fit. My pace of alterations has slowed in recent years. Am I upset? No! I am not even looking at new gear which is a good thing! (very happy)
Johnk has been on this thread for a long time and has made some valid points but I believe he is a horn speaker builder.
I have said on here many times I would not want to build speakers with Duelund parts and try and make money!
Do the parts matter? YES! Would I want to use them build speakers to make money? NO!