I currently own Pass X-250 & X-3 amps, and will be receiving a new Pass X2.5 preamp tomorrow, actually.
I too have considered tubes in a preamp, but have decided to remain on the fully-balanced SS side since I am already there with the Pass amps, just for system synergy sake along with the points made above (impedance matching, gain settings, etc).
I don't know if all that really matters in the grand scheme, but I have no chance to audition comparable products in-home, so I try to avoid gambling too radically by using educated guesses gleaned from research of online reviews and conversations like this one. It's still a crap-shoot, as everyone hears things differently, but that's when you start to appreciate the Black Art that is involved in this horribly finicky (and expensive) hi-end audio world!
Sorry I couldn't give you any comparisons.