I think your idea is great. Changing amps will without a doubt help. Your only consideration is do you want the center channel to have the same amp as the left and right? Do you use theater much?
I would advise borrowing an amp or grabbing a demo from a dealer for a night. See if it makes a difference. I would avoid tubes or class A rated amps if your whole family is going to use the theater and abuse or leave the amp on.
You might even want to consider a nice little 3 or 5 channel amp. The sony, marantz, B&k, Anthem and more all make nice 5 channel amps that you should be able to pick up for under $1000
I would advise borrowing an amp or grabbing a demo from a dealer for a night. See if it makes a difference. I would avoid tubes or class A rated amps if your whole family is going to use the theater and abuse or leave the amp on.
You might even want to consider a nice little 3 or 5 channel amp. The sony, marantz, B&k, Anthem and more all make nice 5 channel amps that you should be able to pick up for under $1000