Who u gots da most uv???


I was digging through my musical selections tonight and stumbled across an idea for a thread. It's threads like these that sometimes end up turning us onto music / bands that we might not have otherwise been aware of or checked into. Since i'm always on the prowl for something new and different, i figured that others might be in the same boat.

Having said that, what band or performer do you have the most recordings by? Personally, i was kind of shocked to see what the answer was in my own case. That is, it's a band called "Skyclad". While a rather unique and popular band in Europe, you'll have a hard time finding their recordings here in the USA. With very witty and twisted lyrics courtesy of Martin Walkyier and various Celtic musical influences from a female "fiddle" player, this band blends old world European influenced folk music with modern day metal. Most of the lyrics are scathing satires of various political and social situations, making them easy to love and hate at the same time. That is, i love the witticisms and fact that Martin's lyrics make you think well beyond surface deep, but at the same time, i tend to disagree with many of the ideas / points of view that one uncovers after really thinking about what he's trying to say. This is kind of like eating something bitter and making a face, but still enjoying it enough to go back for more : )

With me owning 14 of their releases, it's not hard to tell that i like them more than dislike them, so that about sums that up. The only thing that i wonder about is that Martin left the band a while back and they've had major line-up changes, so i'm kind of curious as to where they're going as a band and how well they'll pull things off in the future. Obviously, the only way for me to find out is to buy their latest releases : )

How about sharing some comments and maybe a link or two about the band / performer that you have the most recordings by? Mind you, this might not be your favourite bunch of musicians, but they are the ones that you've got the most money invested into : ) Sean
>

PS... Owning a dozen different copies of any given recording doesn't count, so those that collect multiple copies from different pressing plants / formats aren't allowed to count these. They have to be individual releases with different names / titles to them. For those Classical music lovers that want to participate ( and i HIGHLY encourage this ), i see no problem with listing "the 35th movement of Bach", etc... as performed by various conductors / orchestra's. If you are going to do this, please pick out your favourite versions of this piece of work and tell us why you think they stand out amongst your collection of similar works.

sean
Frank Zappa, by far. My personal favourite is "Tinseltown Rebellion" followed by "Does Humour Belong in Music?" Hmmmmm, so many titles come to mind I'm not sure I'd ever be able to limit myself to a few picks. He was a true genius.

Plenty of Jethro Tull, Rush, Blue Rodeo, Tragically Hip, Pink Floyd, Roxy Music, Led Zeppelin, Tom Cochrane, Bare Naked Ladies, and of course Dire Straits/Knopfler.

Perhaps a new thread is due, bands that you wish had put out more material before fading way and/or breaking up?
Surprising results (to me at least): across all formats, it comes to effectively a nine-way tie: Bill Evans, Miles Davis, Duke Ellington, J.S. Bach, Arvo Part, XTC, Beatles, Pink Floyd and by virtue of number of hours of music rather than number of works, Wagner.

Great thread with great music. Thanks Sean! Lots of stuff for me to try out in the months ahead (just wish this thread had come a couple of weeks ago when the local stores were having sales!).
You folks are probably doing what i did i.e. digging up old stuff that you forgot you had and giving them a spin. It's amazing how many good discs we have that end up collecting dust just because we forget about them.

I expected to see stuff like the Beatles, Stones, the Dead and possibly even Hawkwind due to the volume of releases and age of the band, but i'm pretty surprised at how many different discs / recordings that some have of Neil Young. While i know that he's no spring chicken ( like most of us ), i had no idea that he had that many recordings available. I'm guessing that at least a good portion has to be live bootleg recordings, etc...

As far as Classical music goes, the fact that you can have 100+ versions of the same Beethoven piece by a million different artists is confusing as hell to us that aren't well versed in this type of music. That's why i mentioned that it would be good to share specific recordings of specific pieces i.e. your experience in this area can help some of us find the cream of the crop and maybe help to widen our appreciation of Classical music.

Personally, i'll stick "spin-off" bands with the main band that they splintered from until the "spin-off" has several discs of their own in my collection. Then i'll give them their own space.

Speaking of spin-off or "off-shoot" bands, what bands came out of / were related to the Pixies? This is a band that i'm not familiar with but i've been told ( a million times ) that i would really like. Maybe i'll have heard some of their "siblings".

As far as Skyclad goes, i've got some Sabbat and loved it, hence my search for more of Martin's work, which turned up Skyclad. He's now doing Return To The Sabbat, which i hope to pick up soon.

Glad you like the thread and i hope that others will contribute. The more specific we can be, the more likely we are to picque someone else's curiosity about that band / performers. After all, if "Billy Bob" likes them enough to buy XX amount of their recordings, maybe there's something to them : ) Sean
>

PS... The subject line above where your response goes gets cut off when you enter a post. As such, we end up losing any info, names, comments entered there. Please don't enter data there as not knowing what was said there sometimes changes the meaning or level of understanding of your post due to getting cut off. This is something that Agon needs to address and should delete. Hopefully, they'll read this and take note : ) Sean
>