Shasta: I think that you are "somewhat lucky" if you don't have any form of industry near you and your neighbors aren't generating and pumping electrical hash back into the AC lines. As such, I don't think that AC line noise is "over-hyped", but i think that many of the products sold to deal with such a situation are. As i've always tried to stress in many of my posts, you don't always get what you pay for and brand names in many ( if not most ) cases mean very little when it comes to "tweaks".
Just as Marty stated, most of the "brand name" ( and quite costly ) products that he tested failed miserably using what is a very basic AC diagnostic tool. This is not to say that EVERYBODY has line noise and there is AC distortion EVERYWHERE, but that some folks should be using devices of this type while others have probably wasted a GREAT deal of money. That is money that could have been spent elsewhere resulting in greater joy and benefits to the end user.
Then again, one would not know how well any product works if they were relying on a review or reviewer to tell them. The fact that most reviewers don't have the tools or knowledge to verify if these "PLC's" and similar items are really working or not should make most folks quite leary about their recommendations. On top of that, who is to say that your AC supply lines are even remotely similar to the conditions that they are using to test such a device ? I would bet TALL cash that many folks have invested hundreds if not thousands of dollars in power line conditioning when two or three hundred dollars could pretty much solve most "basic" problems ( if one actually exists ). After that, you are at the point of diminishing returns.
Having said that, i would HIGHLY recommend that folks interested in AC treatment beg, borrow or steal ( no, on second thought, don't do that ) an Audioprism Line Sniffer. Not only will this device let you know if you have a large amount of noise coming in with your AC, it can verify just how well various PLC's and AC tweaks actually work. I'm not saying that it is an "end all" type of tool, but i am saying that the relatively small ( less than $200 ) investment now may save you a LOT of money later. Even if you don't buy one, you should talk to your dealer and see if they loan or rent these out. You can then investigate your own system and AC lines to see if you really do need a PLC of some type and / or find out if the PLC that you have is actually doing anything for you. You can also use this device to track down and repair / replace / remove devices within the house that generate noise. Like i said, it is well worth the investment if you buy one. If you can borrow one and accomplish what you need to do in a short period of time, that is even better ( because it is cheaper : )
Marty: While you witnessed the levels of efficiency in filtering out noise with various PLC's and AC tweaks, the fact that you could not hear a difference at a dealer's showroom does not mean that such a device is not worth owning or the resulting benefits are not audible. Given the way that most installations are thrown together ( literally ) in most shops, it is quite possible that even a mega-dollar, highly reputable brand name system might be lacking in detail and resolution due to a poor installation. Don't discount the experience and knowledge that you learned from that demo. Take the high points of what was shown to you and see if they "might" apply to your system and / or long term listening goals. Even if such knowledge / experience does not come directly into play right now, that does not mean that it won't come in handy at a later date. As i mentioned above, it would be best if you could find out how the devices that actually worked would benefit your system at your house. There are just too many variables when it comes to different systems in different locations running off of different AC grids, etc... Sean
>