Sub Upgrade for Music and Home Theatre


I would like to get some advice on a subwoofer that I would be using for both Music and Home Theatre. The three subwoofers that I am currently considering are:
Talon Roc (Original)
Aerial Accoustics SW-12
Velodyne DD 12
I would be purchasing used and the main spkrs are Tyler Accoustics Linbrooks with outboard crossovers.
Any help in making this decision would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks, Rodney
128x128rross11
The Aerial is VERY good and has great looks as well. The xover built in is very flexable and you can run a sub level in at the same time as a main front in so you can calibrate for both theater and music a little like REL does. The Velodyne is just loud but not very clean or fast and always sounds like a subwoofer. I call it the high end Cerwin Vega. I think you should look for REL as well. Anything at or above the B series but not the Q series. I think the REL is better than the Aerial but you can't go wrong either way.
You might check into the Parts Express/Dayton Reference 12" subs with 1000 watt amps.I'm using a pair of their 10" Reference/aluminum woofers in my AV set-up.Great with music and LFE effects.Articulate,quick and detailed.The "high fidelity" series will be more to your liking than the "high output" woofers.
One reason I like the REL's other than the performance, is because they have two sets of inputs and controls that can be used at the same time. You can set the subwoofer for music through the high filter and for HT through the low filter and forget it.
I recently purchased the 10" Dayton Titanic MK3 sub. I use the sub for music only. It's really amazing for the $$!! It plays loud & clean and is very fast and accurate. I team it up with a pair of Green Mountain Audio Europas. They compliment each other extremely well. The Europas do a really nice job on their own but I wanted that extra low end reinforcement which the Dayton effortlessly provides. For under $500.00, I paid $335.00 delivered, I highly recommend the 10" Mk3 by Dayton. I heard the 12" in very nice also. Jeff