The only screwup was that when initially replacing the tubes, I accidentally installed a 5751 into the spot for a 5755.
The pinout for the two tubes are not the same.
5751
5755
You need to let the guys on AA know about the tube mix up.
I am sure you will get a different set of answers and hopefully some new answers.
You say motor boating? Is the music cutting in and out at a regular pattern?
.