The amp MAY sound very loud, bright and straining because it is clipping or it may be a result of one of the constraints of a single-ended circuit. Single ended amps distortion levels increase substantially as they move closer to their maximum power output, even before clipping.
Some other information will also be useful:
Is the efficiency rating you quoted (89-90) for an 8 or 4
ohm load?
Does the actual impedance vary significantly w frequency?
How big is your room and how far are you from the
speakers?
How loud is "a decent volume level"? Remember a 3dB
volume increase requires a doubling of power.
And yes, it is possible to have too much gain.
Some other information will also be useful:
Is the efficiency rating you quoted (89-90) for an 8 or 4
ohm load?
Does the actual impedance vary significantly w frequency?
How big is your room and how far are you from the
speakers?
How loud is "a decent volume level"? Remember a 3dB
volume increase requires a doubling of power.
And yes, it is possible to have too much gain.