Eton 8.1's or Apogee Slant 6


I'm trying to decide which of the two would be my best choice. I have several amps both tube and solid state to drive them. My room is only 14' x 13'. A box yes. But which of the two do you think would sound the best? I like detail and transparency. I also want dynamics and power at lower listening levels. I have owned Apogees before and really like them but I know nothing of the Eton 8.1's. One last thing I'm using Spicas at the moment and they sound wonderfully with 2 subs. What's your opinion? Which speaker should I consider?
recordho
According to one deep pockets Apogee owner, the Centaur ribbon is second to none. He took out the mid and HF ribbons of his Full Range Apogees, and replaced them with a centaur ribbon. Centaurs do call for a more powerful amp than the Slant 6. I know of a $2k amp that will work wonders with it, if you are interested.

I don't see the 13 by 14 room as big a problem as others. One of my rooms is that big, and I can easily envision the hybrid Apogee there.

As for shipping, if you can afford it, Vintage Trucking specializes in antiques and valuable art. Everything is handled by two men with kid gloves. I have repeatedly shipped Apogees country wide with no problem at all. Just see they are snug in their cases.
Muralman1: "Apogees are not known to do well with subs. It is a mismatch between the fast ribbon and the slower box."

I have to disagree. The integration is pretty good because the boxes are sealed and are very fast. Hybrid speakers are fairly common, even these days. In fact, it is the bigger Apogees that do not integrate with slow subs in the market.

"They are very inefficient and need need plenty of power"
They do need power but they are more efficient than the all ribbons Apogees. The C-Major woofer needs a lot of power while its ribbon is easier to drive.

"Finally, these things are almost impossible to ship easily "

If you have the boxes then they are easier to ship compared to all ribbon Apogees because there is no danger of the ribbon diaphram getting ripped.

Recordho: The Quads will not give the bass. The Quad has better midrange than the C-Major but the latter is very very close plus with tremendous bass. Email me if you want more information.

"According to one deep pockets Apogee owner, the Centaur ribbon is second to none. He took out the mid and HF ribbons of his Full Range Apogees, and replaced them with a centaur ribbon."

Excuse me? Me, deep pocket? Did I win a lottery that you know and I do not?
Hi Mr. Gallant, did I name names???? Now that you have taken your bow, I want you to know I held up the example of the Centaur mated with the FR because I wanted to make the point the Centaur ribbon is highly valued.

For those reading this thread, go to Gallant's system to see what I am talking about.

Those gorgeous Rosewood Centaurs are still their for the taking. They are in Oregon.
Maybe you would like Klipsch kg4's in that small room?...I have a pair and I like them a lot. (you can find them for 2-$300).

I had Apogee Centaur Minors in the past, and I still own Apogee Duetta Signatures, and Apogee Stage (MiniGrands).

I should have a pair of tweaked, and upgraded Klipsch Forte in a few days....a logical step up from my Kg4's in my fairly large room.

Note: My Kg4's aren't for sale

Dave
muralman: I took your point but then I enjoy picking on you also, in case you still have not noticed :)

Yes, seriously, I love the C-Major ribbon and even after may years since I discovered it I have been faithfully sticking with and it has been faithflly serving me.