It appears that even the very best can't extract everything from the groove. Yes, along with table/arm. Is there any way, theoretically speaking, to take cartridge design and execution to a much higher level? What about laser instead of cartridge/arm? I know there was/is one company that tried. It didn't sound better and required cleaning records before each play. But laser could be improved. This approach didn't take off, it would seem.
Raul, Whether it is possible or not to get everything out of tape is an interesting question for a different thread. Vinyl was never supposed to be an audiophile medium but tape was. Anyway, as you say some vintage cartridges can compete with very best modern ones. I am sure some here will question this statement. Not me, I have no idea. Some day I may try that Japanese laser turntable, I would now if not the cost.
[quote]Vinyl was never supposed to be an audiophile medium but tape was.[/quote]
This statement is flat out false. I own a Westerex 3D LP mastering system mounted on a Scully lathe; its pretty evident just from reading the manual that the intention was the best performance possible, and FWIW when the unit was manufactured, it had distortion and bandwidth specs (30KHz bandwidth on any LP is no worries at all) that put the best tape to shame. The limitation in the LP is usually not the media or its playback apparatus, its the source (which is usually tape but these days is also digital). When you hear what direct-to-disk can do then you really realize how far ahead of tape the LP format really is.
Atmasphere, there are totally different opinions, don't present what you say as a truth. Nor do I think that many would agree with you. Direct to disc is not considered the ultimate sound by everyone at all. I'll repeat my opinion - vinyl is a mass market format. Can sound excellent though.
You must have a verified phone number and physical address in order to post in the Audiogon Forums. Please return to Audiogon.com and complete this step. If you have any questions please contact Support.