Going to NYC from the outback of Oregon.

Agree with Audio Connection as one of the finest shops in the NY metro area. John and Nick are fabulous and I've purchased more stuff from AC than any other dealership. But everything depends on what the customer is looking for. When in NYC, one should also check the brands carried by Stereo Exchange, Ears Nova, Lyric HiFi, Sound By Singer, Innovative Audio/Video, In Living Stereo, Audioarts, High Water Sound and others. In short, it's probably one of the best places in the country to demo and/or purchase high end audio equipment. 

Academy Records, 18th St & 5th Ave.
Rock, Jazz, Classical, Blues, Soul... Google them first.

Great advise! I will definitely try to hit most of the places mentioned.
Has the Audio Pimp (Johnny) resurfaced? I know he may have had some legal issues. I was hoping to visit his store someday.
Again, thanks for the pointers and have a great Christmas.