Ahh Lewm......the Master of illogical analogies.
Firstly we have the "rowboat in the floating sea" analogy whereby the stable platform of your shelf or rack is likened to the unruly fluid of the sea and the vibrations which uniformly affect the rigid shelf are compared to the multifarious currents and winds acting on a thermal fluid in constant motion.
In this ludicrous juxtaposition.....he then places two separate boats instead of one contiguous raft...
But now Lewm surpasses himself....the results of a person jumping off a roof are well known to be less than happy whereas the results of a person using outboard armpods are so far universally 'happy'. So how goes the analogy....❓
But I also can be somewhat amused with "thought experiments"
The Kenwood L-07D
http://i.imgur.com/VvgdWQi.jpgwhich directly connects its platter bearing to its tonearm support via a cast aluminium structure, condemns the fixed mounting dimension of the tonearm to expand and contract with changes in temperature. Over a 10 centigrade degree range, this dimension could possibly change by a few millimetres rendering your carefully executed arm geometry useless.
Furthermore....connecting the arm support directly to the supporting spindle of the platter, inevitably transfers all the vibrations of the revolving platter into the arm base, a design failure of mammoth proportion.
The belief that all turntable designers (and designs) of the past were competent is a demonstrable unfortunate absurdity.