Just to update everything here. The new amplifier arrived and does not have the same buzz/whine that the other one did. I can hear it running, but I can hear all the other electronics in my office as well. I may have a tiny DC offset or something and I'm going to try the Emotiva cmx-2. The new unit is basically perfect for my needs.
Again, I want to thank Peachtree for the awesome customer support and Needle Doctor for letting me work with Peachtree without worry about return window. I highly recommend both.
I'm just hoping that I don't get the upgrade bug that seems to hit everyone else on the forums. :)