Do we really need anything more than 8" woofer and 1" tweeter for medium size room?


With the right electronics good 8" can go down very low and relatively clean. And if that's not enough, well, two 10" subs would do it. 
Opinions?
inna
Don't remember his name, there is a French designer who makes great drivers used in some esoteric speakers. That driver goes down to about 40hz and up as far as you can see or hear. I think, it's 10" driver but not sure. The quality of that driver really impressed many people. I even watched an interview with him. Basically, he is a one man operation. Old world craftsmanship.
I'm pretty sure you are referring to PHY...

We had a set of those 10" units in a box, made by an associate of PHY. The boxes were rather large, and built like an acoustic guitar body- designed to resonate as a means of extending the bass of the 10" driver. Overall, the little HEAs we have with the 6" woofers play deeper and more accurate bass.
Yeah, that's it, PHY. Bass is not the strongest virtue of those drivers.
Classic Audio people sound very serious to me. Never heard their speakers and not going to for now - I might like them a lot and I am quite certain that I can't afford them. They are big too.
I think that most listeners especially older ones like myself understand, there seem to be two types of bass sound, the big woofer sound, fat not deep but move lots of air and seem to fulfill most listeners of that enjoy that genera. The newer style is the smaller woofer that is fast and tight, more accurate, but not as big of a sound. Which sound that you prefer 
Inna

That is the key isn't it. The goal for  me is to enjoy the music. To hear a high resolution system with no edge, no noise, not analytical and produced in a way that is sounds like it is playing music for me and not just a big expensive PA system. Make the music accessible.