unh... not a fan of McIntosh (except the looks and build quality)
a quantitative assessment is impossible, esp. to 0.1 level
now... Oppo has a wonderful 30 trial policy and it is very fair - you only pay shipping one way
also, they are working on new players
and as a universal player, it will handle video too
you might want to do what I am doing - assembling some program material to really test things carefully
e.g. rip 2 copies of a favorite CD; you will put one copy on each player with a few seconds time lag on one of them and then listen to the exact same passage twice - right after the other one
for material, I usually pick female vocals, something with snare drums (listen for that first impulse 'hit') and high quality recordings/mastering
e.g. I use the famous jazz at the Pawnshop for part of it, even tho it is not my favorite jazz
a quantitative assessment is impossible, esp. to 0.1 level
now... Oppo has a wonderful 30 trial policy and it is very fair - you only pay shipping one way
also, they are working on new players
and as a universal player, it will handle video too
you might want to do what I am doing - assembling some program material to really test things carefully
e.g. rip 2 copies of a favorite CD; you will put one copy on each player with a few seconds time lag on one of them and then listen to the exact same passage twice - right after the other one
for material, I usually pick female vocals, something with snare drums (listen for that first impulse 'hit') and high quality recordings/mastering
e.g. I use the famous jazz at the Pawnshop for part of it, even tho it is not my favorite jazz