Rega Planet or Apollo CD Player

used to sell the planet. You need to match with mellower gear. The Planet is a bit sharp on top - yes, compared to the Apollo, likely.
How about a good transport and dac combo? The Theta's floating around out there are very nice, bel canto's, etc.
Good luck

you can get a great deal on the musical fidelity A5 cd player these days. i have owned two of them over the years and i have found it to be a top notch item.

I would spend more for the Apollo. Others to consider might be the Cambridge Azur's...highly rated and sound terrific...friend has the 740 and it is sweet from bottom to top. Great looking unit and in your price range if you consider prev owned.