Stylus force digital scales


Digital scales from Clearaudio and others range from $200-500. Amazon has 'em for $20. Why cant I use one of these instead and save big bucks?
tbromgard
Folkfreak,  I took a powerful magnet to the weigh pan of my digital VTF scale, and there was zero attraction of the magnet to the weigh pan or even to the body of the scale itself.  Seems that even though your plastic-bodied scale and my metal-bodied scale look alike (maybe exactly alike), there actually was a good reason why mine cost more money, other than the metal outer shell. For once in my life, my extravagance paid off.

nrenter and brf, You both got it right for the wrong reasons.  My physics professor in college would have given you both an "F", but he was mean.  The force of gravity never changes.  What changes is the magnitude of the force vector in the vertical direction, when you rotate the tonearm in a vertical arc away from or down towards the LP surface.  The magnitude of the vertical force vector due to gravity changes because you are shifting the center of mass toward the pivot (if you raise the tonearm) or away from the pivot (if the arm wand moves toward the LP surface).  It's like a seesaw. When you raise the tonearm, some of its mass is shifted toward the pivot and thus the pull of gravity on the cartridge is partly borne by the pivot, not the cantilever, during that moment.  
Lewm, I believe we are saying the same thing if I replace force of gravity "on an abject" with force vector. An object perpendicular to the earth’ surface will experience only one force vector. Anything other than perpendicular, results in more than one force vector and that is (as you obviously know) why balls roll downhill and objects topple if not supported. Thanks for the additional clarification.
All physically true, but, does it matter? The optimal VTF for any given cartridge is an unknown. We could try to measure by incremental adjustments while taking measurements, but the results would always be a range that is dependent on the accuracy and precision of our measuring devices. Plus the recording being played will also determine the outcome and define the parameters and conditions under which the analysis was performed i.e., the so-called asterisk in the footnote. So, the optimal VTF will always be a range, it can't be anything other than that, and, as long as we are in that range, slight variations of up and down motion on the cartridge imparted by the record and that change the VTF ever so slightly as described above simply          won’t          matter.
All physically true, but, does it matter? The optimal VTF for any given cartridge is an unknown
I agree, I only use the stylus force gauge to set the vtf at the manufacture's recommended force and then perform fine adjustments by ear.  Personally, I don't need a scale that measures to the 1,000 of a gram.
@lewm I’d not expect their to be any noticeable attraction (we’re talking about .1g of effect which I’m sure you could not feel)

the test id like to run (which I will when I get home) is to load the platform statically with something non magnetic and then bring a magnet close to the scale and see if the weight reading changes I.e. if the magnetic field has an effect on the weighing mechanism itself.  I’ll report back on what I find out