Vandersteen Treo CT vs Mag 3.7i speakers


I've listened to both at my local dealer.  I have sufficient space for either one in my living room (16x21).  If you have some ideas/a clear opinion on which one to purchase I would very much appreciate hearing from you..thanks.
newton
I have the Maggie 1.7s. I have a fairly large audio room (14' W x 28' L x 10' H) They are about 4' from a treated front wall and am running a ADS-12 sub. So far I am most happy with the 1.7s but then I listen mostly to, light jazz, and contemporary pop or Celtic with good vocals and live acoustic orchestration. I'm considering  moving up to 3.7i  but not sure that my room size warrants the move.
I've long been a Vandi fan and have had the 2c and the 2ci and liked both but, for the style and volume of music I listen to now I truly love the Maggies.
Good luck with your quest...Jim
 

 

Not yet mentioned here is that some find Maggies lacking in low-level dynamics---the ability to go from 0 to 60 in 3 seconds, as more dynamic speakers appear to do. They need to be listened to at higher SPL than other speakers in order to "break through" what is called the "Maggie Mist". At lower volumes, Maggies sound slightly veiled, thick, and slow to some people. That is less true than it used to be, with improvements to the basic magnetic-planar design Magneplanar has been using since the early 70's.

Planars---all of them, not just Maggies---sound very different from box speakers, even one's with as "open" a design as Vandersteens. Some people prefer planar sound to any other, but one doesn't know if that is true of himself until living with them for awhile. Some listeners tire of the planar sound, missing what dynamics and horns do better. As with everything in hi-fi, one must discover his own personal priorities in music reproduction, and find products that excel at those. Magnepan offers a 60-day trial period for their $650/pr MMG. That's a great way to find out if you like the Maggie sound. 

get both....
Vandersteen 7 in my main listening room and a pair of Apogee Stage on sound anchors in my hunting/fishing therapy / work room vintage museum.....

yes they really are apples and oranges....
get both....
Vandersteen 7 in my main listening room and a pair of Apogee Stage on sound anchors in my hunting/fishing therapy / work room vintage museum.....

yes they really are apples and oranges....
@bdp24
while the older Maggies did need a bit of volume to become dynamic and break the veil, the new .7 models sound very nice, even at relatively low volume levels. My ears and head no longer handle hours of loud music and I do most of my listening in the evenings at moderate to low volume levels and am not disappointed, at all, with the performance of my 1.7s. for the music that I most listen to. I do have to agree that the Maggies may not be for everyone, or fit in every environment; always best, as with any speaker or equipment, to audition at one's own home listening to one's own music....Jim