Thanks for the rant!
In this thread and elsewhere, some have opined that Thiels are less forgiving of amps and this lines up well with your comments here. Most Thiels do an excellent job of reproducing the signal fed to them. That is, they are highly resolved, transparent and neutral. But it's a precarious position. Flaws in upstream components (amps, sources, cables, recordings) are more readily heard by listeners. Listeners (and reviewers) with flawed gear might mistakenly blame the speaker as the Thiels reveal the flawed gear.
But the flip side is the possibility - with exemplary amps, sources, and cabling - of standout performance; great musical clarity and emotional connection to the performance. And this is what I'm hearing in system :)
There are further involvements and interactions resulting from coherence that relate to the amplifier discussion above and many more aspects of sonic performance. In business it is impolite to blame the upstream signal chain for less than satisfying sonic results. But truth be told, a coherent speaker doing its (Thiel defined) job of absolutely representing in all domains the input signal fed to it has an impossible job. There are thousands of ways that a signal is corrupted from acoustic (or augmented) event, through the recording, storage and playback chain to reach the listener's ears.
In this thread and elsewhere, some have opined that Thiels are less forgiving of amps and this lines up well with your comments here. Most Thiels do an excellent job of reproducing the signal fed to them. That is, they are highly resolved, transparent and neutral. But it's a precarious position. Flaws in upstream components (amps, sources, cables, recordings) are more readily heard by listeners. Listeners (and reviewers) with flawed gear might mistakenly blame the speaker as the Thiels reveal the flawed gear.
But the flip side is the possibility - with exemplary amps, sources, and cabling - of standout performance; great musical clarity and emotional connection to the performance. And this is what I'm hearing in system :)