I own both the Franks and the Atma-sphere M-60's, and use the amps to drive Coincident Super Victory II's and Coincident Triumph Extreme II's. Let me say at the outset that I love both amps and have no desire to sell either. Several years ago, I did a long and careful audition of the Franks driving PRE's, so I have a good feel for the combo you have. I suspect this will be a tough choice for you, and the best option is to do a long evaluation in your room with your ancillaries with both amps side by side. You already know the virtues of the Franks. What I can tell you is that the M-60's equal the Franks in many respects, but the amps do diverge on some attributes. As you know, and as Ralph has pointed out on numerous occasions, 300B amps are at their best when driven gently. Distortion rises rapidly above 1-2 W output. For me, that is an issue. I listen to a lot of orchestral music, so rising distortion became an issue driving the 92.5 dB efficient SVII's. Rising distortion will never trouble you with your PREs driven by M-60's. If you mostly listen to small scale works, with peak volumes at or below 90dB in a smallish room, rising distortion may not be a significant issue. You will find the M-60's lack some of the wonderful sonority of the Franks, but not much, provided that you select good driver tubes to replace the awful (in my opinion) Chinese 6SN7s that are stock. I really favor the NOS RCA 6SN7s, myself. For me those tubes bring some of the 300B virtues to the M-60's. The less expensive 1960's vintage 6SN7GB tubes are fine. It is not necessary to use the uber expensive 40's and 50's vintage tubes. Also relevant is that I ordered my M-60s with the V-cap upgrade and the power supply upgrade. I do hope you are able to arrange a long audition with the M-60's having an appropriate driver tube compliment, and I will be very interested in your conclusions.
Atma-Sphere in CO?
I'm looking to listen to one of Ralph's amps. I'm in Denver and have Coincident PREs and a pair of Coincident's wonderful 300b Frankenstein's if anyone's interested in doing a comparison. Obviously the speakers won't travel, but I'd be willing to pack up the amps and do some driving.
Will probably catch AS at RMAF, but would also love to do a home based A/B comparison...
Will probably catch AS at RMAF, but would also love to do a home based A/B comparison...
- ...
- 43 posts total
- 43 posts total