2. music
  3. 138581-2248

The current best band in the world?

There is of course no such thing. There’s not even a best Blues band, or Rock band, or Jazz band, or Country band, or any other kind of band. But a lot of us probably have a "favorite" band, one we like so much it is our favorite irrespective of genre. And so it is for me.

A band is the combined talents of all it’s members, different bands having varying distributions of talent levels amongst it’s members. There is a band that has been playing together now for 16 years, and damn are they good. It’s Marty Stuart and His Fabulous Superlatives, and they are my current favorite band. All four members are extremely talented, and they work together as only the very best bands do.

Marty Stuart went on the road in a Gospel group at age 12, playing mandolin for the Summer before returning to school. He was caught in class reading a Country music magazine hidden in a history book, and explained to the teacher he would rather make history than read about it. He was expelled, so looked for a job. Lester Flatt hired him, and Marty went on the road with him at age 13. He worked with Lester until Flatt’s failing health took him off the road in ’78, then kicked around a little with Vassar Clements and Doc Watson. In 1980 he was hired by Johnny Cash, with whom he worked for years. Marty got himself a record deal, and put out a bunch of albums on MCA and Columbia. I met him at The Palomino (the legendary Country music bar in North Hollywood, where Dwight Yoakam got his start) in the early 90’s, and a nicer guy you couldn’t find. He owns a bunch of historic guitars, including Pop Staple’s acoustic and Clarence White’s (The Byrds) Telecaster.

Drummer Harry Stinson is a superb musician and singer, long employed in Nashville studios in both capacities. Guitarist Kenny Vaughan is a Telecaster ace whom I first saw live playing guitar in Lucinda Williams’ band, on the Car Wheels tour. He’s also a real good harmony singer, with his own recent solo album. Bassist Chris Scruggs, Grandson of Earl Scruggs, is an incredible multi-instrumentalist (a first-call pedal steel player in Nashville) and, again, good harmony singer. Country musicians grow up singing as well as playing instruments.

All these guys are seasoned pros, talented not only on the instruments they play, but also as ensemble players; those are very different talents. Their latest album, Way Out West, was produced by Petty’s guitarist Mike Campbell, he also a big fan of Marty Stuart and His Fabulous Superlatives. Great band name!

128x128bdp24
n80
2,116 posts
 
Too many obscure bands in this list. And maybe what I'm going to say should refer to the best 'group' in the world if we accept bdp24's distinction between group vs band.

But the best group in the world and ever is the Rolling Stones. And no, I'm not a fanboy. I don't even own any of their music except their recent blues album. But, they were there at the beginning and they are still here (more or less). That alone is an unparalleled feat. But, they are also immensely popular, have been immensely influential and even if they contain no single virtuouso...well, Mick maybe...as a group they have gelled for decades. They have (had) charisma and presence and have been in the broad public consciousness for decades.

Just listing bands we happen to like isn't helpful in the 'contest' thread like this. There has to be more weight than "I like them".
bdp24's avatar
bdp24 OP
9,757 posts
 
@n80, so you consider The Stones the "current" best band/group in the world? I can see a person wanting to bestow upon them best
"all-time" (whether I or anyone else agrees with that or not), but current? I'm not sure even they would still be self-proclaiming that to be the case. There is a revealing story about them Ry Cooder has told regarding when they had him come over to England to record with them after Brian's Jones death, but I'll save that for another time. It's not flattering ;-) .
geoffkait's avatar
geoffkait
23,365 posts
 
The Stones are presently the oldest band in the world. One of my fav videos on YouTube shows the Stones and their wives leaving Bill Wyman’s 80th birthday get together. But seriously you have to give them credit, having just completed a big European tour, including Poland.
n80
2,116 posts
 
bdp24, you have pretty tight criteria some of which might be more implicit than explicit.

But if by current you mean either new music being produced or playing previous music at the highest possible level, then no, The Stones don't fit that bill.

What Cooder has to say about the Stones is irrelevant. The Stones are The Stones. I remember Ian Anderson....and Billy Idol for that matter, disrespecting Led Zep. All it did was make them look foolish and petty.

So if by current you mean absolutely on the top of their game at this very moment then the answer is The Struts. They are everything they claim to be and try to be, in every possible way. Their tunes are catchy and pop centered. Their live shows are amazing. Yes, they are breaking previously plowed ground, but it has been a long time since that ground was broken and their doing a great job at it....in some ways better than their forebears.

For me they are the "current" best band in the world.
bdp24's avatar
bdp24 OP
9,757 posts
 
I think Weezer are a great band. They strike me as being a blend of The Ramones and AC/DC, with their own approach and personality. I love 'em!
More to discover