I can tell you without a doubt that WC will not be disappointed with the Martin Logan Neolith speakers.
I don't know where this is coming from that eventually one will be disappointed with electrostatics. Where is that coming from?
I have had electrostatics for quite some time. Sequel IIs and Monolith IIIs. Also, I have several friends that have electrostatics and they are quite happy. I use my Monolith IIIs with the Krell KBX balanced electronic crossover designed for the Monolith IIIs, with a Audio Research REF 6 pre-amp, REF 2SE phono stage, REF 250 amps (for the uppeer panels), Mark Levinson 23.5 amp for the woofers, Audio Research DAC 8, Sota Star vacuum turntable, SME IV arm and I am quite happy. Oh Yeah!!!!
My imaging is wonderful. The soundstage wide and accurate, dimensionality, spot on.
I spoke with the Martin Logan representatives at the RMAF and they said the Neolith was based on the Monolith III Speakers. I also spoke with Gale Sanders while he was demonstrating his new speakers at the RMAF and he grinned, took me aside and said quietly that the Monolith III speakers are still the best today. Especially with the KBX crossover and peerless woofers.
So, WC can go with the Magico speakers and will also not be disappointed. I realy like those speakers. But, don't let the words of people that don't own electrostatics, or are biased against them turn you away from them.
The bass response I am getting is spot on and accurate as measured by monitoring equipment. I actually added a subwoofer to see if it was needed and guess what? it wasn't. It didn't add anything. So I removed it.
As usual, the room, room treatment, appurtenant equipment, etc. play a great role in the speakers. as well as speaker setup. Which many people flat out get wrong.
I'll take the Neoliths in an instant. The 15a's too me weren't better than the Monolith IIIs with the KBX crossover to justify changing. But the Neoliths and If I had the room, the statement II's (I'd take in an instant also).
In my opinion, speakers are (to me) the hardest piece to decide on.
I ordered new upper panels for the Monolith IIIs from Martin Logan. I was thinking that my panels that I replaced in 2006 were maybe light on the highs. so I ordered new panels. Turns out they were fine. Other things affected the highs that I corrected. But, I'll have new panels next week anyway.
If you aren't a serial killer, bring your favorite music over and you will see (hear) that the Martin Logan's are accurate and really sing.
As a former (sigh!) musician. First chair violinist. Sax, Bassoon, Oboe, etc. I can tell you that in my opinion accuracy is most important to me. If it doesn't sound accurate and is altered (too much bass, instruments don't sound real, etc.) I'm leaving.
enjoy