I read sometime last year that the regulatory agency for the utility companies relaxed the standard for 60 Hz, because it was too expensive and time consuming for the utilities. So some type of device/app is now needed, that is not dependent on power company frequency.
Stroboscopic disk sets wrong speed for turntable?
Hi all! I am new here.
I have just set up my Clearaudio concept turntable. Unfortunately, the speed of the turntable was wrong so I had to reset it. In order to do this I have used two methods: an iPhone app called RPM; the stroboscopic disk + the iPhone app StrobeLight.
The problem is that when everything is correct at 33 1/3 (both verified with the RPM app and the stroboscopic disk), the songs are playing one semitone lower than what they should. In order to make them play at the correct note, I have to set the speed at around 34 RMP as shown by the RPM app. Also the stroboscopic disk shows that now I am going faster than the 33 1/3, being consistent with the RMP app. How is this possible? Am I doing something wrong or even the stroboscopic disk is not accurate enough? Could it be the StrobeLight app not being an accurate enough light source for the stroboscopic disk? It is just peculiar that both the RMP app and the stroboscopic disk are consistent in saying that I am going too fast.
Any help is much appreciated. Thanks!
I have just set up my Clearaudio concept turntable. Unfortunately, the speed of the turntable was wrong so I had to reset it. In order to do this I have used two methods: an iPhone app called RPM; the stroboscopic disk + the iPhone app StrobeLight.
The problem is that when everything is correct at 33 1/3 (both verified with the RPM app and the stroboscopic disk), the songs are playing one semitone lower than what they should. In order to make them play at the correct note, I have to set the speed at around 34 RMP as shown by the RPM app. Also the stroboscopic disk shows that now I am going faster than the 33 1/3, being consistent with the RMP app. How is this possible? Am I doing something wrong or even the stroboscopic disk is not accurate enough? Could it be the StrobeLight app not being an accurate enough light source for the stroboscopic disk? It is just peculiar that both the RMP app and the stroboscopic disk are consistent in saying that I am going too fast.
Any help is much appreciated. Thanks!
- ...
- 24 posts total
bgpowell I read sometime last year that the regulatory agency for the utility companies relaxed the standard for 60 Hz, because it was too expensive ...I think your memory is failing you. First, there is no single regulatory agency for power distribution. Rather, regulation is left to individual states. In the US, there are numerous distinct electric power distribution grids and they are managed by the non-profit NERC. It ensures reliability and sets the standards power suppliers must observe. Among them is power line frequency. Power line frequency is tightly controlled within each regional grid. That is because each regional grid is supplied with power from multiple energy providers and all of that power must be properly synchronized (within tolerance) for the system to be reliable. The actual voltage provided by individual suppliers has a fairly wide tolerance - but not so the frequency. The stability of the each regional grid hinges in large part on that tight synchronization of power, which is typically around ± .5 hZ. If imbalance between load and demand causes a substantial frequency deviation, automatic relays will shed load to preserve the frequency and the stability of the remainder of the system. Of course, that may not be a tight enough spec for audiophiles using a synchronous motor on their turntables. For them, there are products such as the VPI SDS or ADS, and other products such as PS Audio’s regenerators. |
I agree with Lewm that the battery powered KAB strobe would be the best way to go. When I purchased his Walker motor controller for my Nottingham TT I first used a generic disc and a AC powered bulb to set speed. Then a friend loaned me his KAB strobe and lo and behold it showed the AC setup was slightly slow. Not cheap but highly recommended! |
Sorry my memory was a bit faulty, it was a proposal by the North American Reliability Corporation (NERC), an pro power industry organization. There is a Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) which made Time Error Correction mandatory in 2009. NERC put a second successful proposal to FERC, which is contingent upon the removal of the standard WEQ-006. Anyway, not implemented yet but there is pressure. |
- 24 posts total