"If you had say $7k to spend would you pick a 10 yrs $15-18k speaker or a newer $7-10k speaker?"
At the risk of stating the obvious, I'd pick the speaker most likely to have the characteristics I was looking for. In other words, I suggest making the comparison based on performance rather than based on some combination of age and price. Assuming auditioning isn't feasible I'd try to make my guess as well-educated as possible, which might involve buying and reading a book or two.
Duke