Whats that sound with Volume set to off?


I have two turntables, Using the same cartridge and tracking force with volume off, I can really hear the music from the record while the other turntable the cartridge is relatively silent.  Why?
tzh21y
Post removed 
thanks. It was just interesting how much of a difference there was.  It sure does not sound like a good thing.  i was wondering if my grooves were getting destroyed lol.
Post removed 
I find it hard to believe that there is no damage to the record when its that loud.