2. analog
  3. 147896-78132

Merrill GEM Dandy PolyTable vs. Well Tempered Amadeus

I'm looking to upgrade turntables, going from vintage to modern and am looking at mid-priced options ($2000-$3500).
The two tables that keep coming up are George Merrill's GEM Dandy PolyTable (or SuperTable with 12" tonearm) and models by Well Tempered, most likely the Amadeus Mk ii. Thinking of running the Hana SL or similar on either table...

Has anyone else considered these two options and (hopefully) auditioned each? Thoughts: re: PolyTable vs. Super12? Amadeus vs. other Well Tempered models?

My setup: Odyssey Audio Kismet mono amps, Odyssey Tempest preamp (with MM/MC phono stage), Klipsch Cornwall I speakers, Anti-cables speaker wire & interconnects.

Why these two tables - both designers have embraced outside-the-box thinking rather than traditional designs on steroids, both focus on dark backgrounds, both are dampened tables; less fuss, more listening.

Thanks!

scoran
arturos73
38 posts
 
I bought the Super 12 Polytable from George less than a year ago and have been very pleased with it. The built quality is solid and the performance is spectacular. The external motor runs with dead quiet precision. I am using a Orotofon 2M Black, but in hindsight I probably would have opted for the Hana. No regrets with the Polytable purchase. Give George a call if you have any concerns or questions. He is a wealth of knowledge and even sent me his turntable/cartridge setup manual that he authored. A great guy!
fjn04
1,561 posts
 
You are certainly on the right track. Exactly what I would be considering in that price range. I own an Amadeus (mk. 1)  now, and still enjoy it in a second system. It really sings with an EMT Tsd series, and Charisma (Denon) 103. I'd also like to hear the Mo-Fi with a good MC. 
scoran OP
10 posts
 
@arturos73 - I spoke with George shortly before after the original PolyTable came out and agree he's one of the good guys. I really need to hear each table, but I don't live close to dealers for either model, so in the meantime hoping to hear from those who have auditioned either or both designs.
scoran OP
10 posts
 
@fjn04 - thank for mentioning the Denon 103. Definitely one I'd consider, or a modded variant. I'm also curious about the Mo-Fi Ultradeck, but thinking the PolyTable and Well Tempered have dampening that's more forgiving in my room.
More to discover