@millercarbon,
"Still, one has to admit, the way the phono stage knows to make the tick happen every time the record comes around, is pretty impressive."
Cruel, but funny. I guess you just couldn't resist popping that particular balloon.
Joking aside, this can be a big issue for some audiophiles.
There's no question that certain turntable/arm/cartridge combinations can handle vinyl imperfections in a far less intrusive way than others, eg the new Technics decks are said to be good in this regard.
If this is a side effect of tracking it should be expected that better decks will perform better in this regard. Lower rumble and noise should help too by improving the music to noise ratio.
There's also the question of siting as I've found that certain platforms such as glass seem to enhance those pesky clicks and pops instead of reducing them.
Finally, its worrying that with such high prices for 180 gram vinyl here in the UK hardly a single LP is blemish free. We were surprised to find, during one vinyl playing session, that 1970s records seemed to be quieter and less click infested than most brand new records.
Not encouraging. I know its a pain but I would urge anyone affected to demand a swap or their money back. Probably the only way consumers can get the manufacturers to tighten up quality control.