I definitely am considering a Marantz TT-15S1 because of the Clearaudio Virtuoso cat. I have heard really good things about both, but not actually listened either. My plan originally was to sell both the Alva and the Pro-Ject, which ideally would give me enough for a $1500 table with cart.
I had a Marantz TT-15S. I liked its minimalism. Forum members (different forum) extolled the virtues of a SL1200 and I gave into that. Looking back from a distance it was a no-brainer. A Direct Drive is so much fuller. (You only have to look at the chink in the belt on the Marantz) The ease of use too, is a benefit of the Technics. I was very happy with it and did many upgrades. They look so cool too and I actually put one in my office (Property Lawyer) and it makes a great centerpiece!
As a general remark though I would say that vinyl is fun but to get good sound - and you really can get good sound - you have to invest time or dosh. My HI-Fi story is that I have spread myself a bit thin on sources (PC, TT, Disc Spinner). Have one good source and save dosh that can go to amp or speakers.