Wagner, Barenboim, Said, Israel
quote from Said article
In any event, Wagner’s works in Israel have
by common consent been left unperformed, until 7 July, 2001. Barenboim
is head of the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, as well as the Berlin State
Opera, whose orchestra he was leading on tour in Israel for the three
consecutive concerts presented in Jerusalem. He had originally scheduled
a performance of Act One of Wagner’s opera Die Walkure for the 7 July
concert, but had been asked to change it by the director of the Israel
Festival, which had invited the German orchestra and Barenboim in the
first place. Barenboim substituted a programme of Schumann and
Stravinsky, and then, after playing those, turned to the audience and
proposed a short extract from Wagner’s Tristan and Isolde as an encore.
He opened the floor to a discussion, which ensued with people for and
against. In the end, Barenboim said he would play the piece but
suggested that those who were offended could leave, which some in fact
did. By and large though, the Wagner was well received by a rapturous
audience of about 2800 Israelis and, I am sure, extremely well
performed.
Still, the attacks on Barenboim have not
stopped. It was reported in the press on 25 July that the Knesset
committee on culture and education “urged Israel’s cultural bodies to
boycott the conductor… for performing music by Hitler’s favourite
composer at Israel’s premier cultural event until he apologises.” The
attacks on Barenboim by the minister of culture and other luminaries
have been venomous, even though despite his birth and early childhood in
Argentina, he himself has always thought of himself as an Israeli. He
grew up there, he went to Hebrew schools, he carries an Israeli passport
along with his Argentinian one. Besides, he has always been thought of
as a major cultural asset to Israel, having been a central figure in the
country’s musical life for years and years, despite the fact that,
since he was in his teens, he has lived in Europe and the United States
most of the time, not in Israel.
read whole article here
https://www.mediamonitors.net/barenboim-and-the-wagner-taboo/