As long as they are transparent about being dealers, as well as which lines they sell and don’t sell, I think dealers can be additive to the discussion. I’m sure it is hard to be objective, though, talking about equipment you can’t sell vs what you can sell.
What bugs me more is *any* contributor who thinks that because they heard one model of one brand, perhaps not even recently, that they have the “expertise and experience” to tell you how all the models sound and will interact with other equipment. I don’t buy it. Several dealers’ characterizations of my equipment have been wildly off the mark to me. Subjectively, of course, but that’s exactly they reason they are unlikely to get that kind of speculation right. I even saw two dealers get the specs wildly wrong on equipment they supposedly knew well.
But I wouldn’t ban anyone for it. Everyone talks book. Everyone. So their book should be visible.
What bugs me more is *any* contributor who thinks that because they heard one model of one brand, perhaps not even recently, that they have the “expertise and experience” to tell you how all the models sound and will interact with other equipment. I don’t buy it. Several dealers’ characterizations of my equipment have been wildly off the mark to me. Subjectively, of course, but that’s exactly they reason they are unlikely to get that kind of speculation right. I even saw two dealers get the specs wildly wrong on equipment they supposedly knew well.
But I wouldn’t ban anyone for it. Everyone talks book. Everyone. So their book should be visible.