Simaudio 810lp vs. Brinkmann Edison phono stage


Has anyone compared the Simaudio 810lp phono stage vs. Brinkmann Edison phono stage, or other similarly priced and performing phono stages, tube or solid state.

Using MC cart, balanced or unbalanced.

Thanks on advance for your comments.
jon47
Raul, I have no comment on your other statements, but 600 to 1000 ohms is not really a problem for driving almost any amplifier one might want to use, including solid state types.  Not many amplifiers present an input impedance below 10K ohms.  Even such an amplifier, if it does exist, could be driven pretty well from a 1000-ohm source.  So, I would not eliminate the Brinkmann from consideration solely based on that parameter. But that's just my opinion.

As an aside, I also have to wonder at your statement: "The worst place to handle an audio signal is in a phono stage no matters what."  Do you know of any phono stages that don't handle audio signals?  If so, what are they handling?
Dear @lewm  : Problem with high output impedance in a preamp is that high frequency range could be affected through the signal " trip " in the IC to de amp not that exist or could exist a problem with the amp.

The worst place to use tubes is at phono stage units.

R.
I think Helmut Brinkmann is not only a great engineer but a musical vinyl fanatic, always always great sounding gear IMO

Dear @gestalt : That 810LP outperforms easily the Lamm  or any other tube alternative. Tubes are not for phono stage that you like it does not means is rigth because is a wrong wrong way to go when today exist several SS good designs for that cartridge handled.

R.