NEVER short pin3 to pin1 on a balanced XLR output.@danip
It’s never a good idea to say "never" :-)
As my previous posts should make clear, I agree with your post when it comes to most designs. But there are exceptions.
You referred to balanced output stages utilizing op amps, and a notable exception to the general guideline of not shorting pin 3 to pin 1 when adapting a balanced output to an unbalanced input applies to op amp-based output stages that are "cross-coupled," which thereby provide outputs that are essentially floating with respect to circuit ground. See pages 11 and 12 of the following reference, in which such circuits are referred to as "active floating sources." And note the statement on page 13 that "Grounding one output line at the driver, which is REQUIRED [emphasis added] to guarantee stability of most "active floating" circuits, degenerates the interface to a completely unbalanced one having no ground noise rejection at all."
https://www.jhbrandt.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/Design_of_High-Performance_Balanced_Audio_Interfaces.pdf
That is further confirmed in the Rane document that was referenced earlier in the thread by Rauda1. See diagram 6 on page 7 of that document.
Also, while I’m not specifically familiar with the designs of the output stages of Atma-Sphere’s balanced tube-based preamps, Ralph (Atmasphere) has explicitly stated in past threads here that connecting the balanced outputs of his preamps to unbalanced inputs without grounding pin 3 will result in a huge hum. Which can be expected, given that the balanced outputs of his preamps, although not transformer coupled, are nevertheless floating with respect to circuit ground. And consequently if pin 3 is not grounded the signal on pin 2 will be received by the destination component with an uncontrolled and undefinable voltage relative to pin 1.
There are undoubtedly other such examples.
Regards,
-- Al