Never really gave Maxell tapes a fair shot.
Once I tried TDK SA I stuck with them.
I always preferred Maxell to TDK, although I have a bunch of TDK.
Being a dealer, I think I sold almost every brand of tape, at one time or another.
My Favorites:
3M BlackWatch
Denon
Fuji
Maxell
Nakamichi
TDK
That's
Least Favorites:
BASF (awful)
DAK (double awful)
Memorex
Radio Shack/Realistic
Recoton
Scotch
The Nakamichi tape was just hand picked TDK, (from the middle of the pancake reel. Supposed to be more uniform). It was fine, but IMHO, no better than the TDK equivalent.