@slaw, I understand why I can be viewed as a Beatles basher, and for that I have only myself to blame. I in fact love both Rubber Soul and Revolver, and many individual songs on their other albums. I also love the "Paperback Writer"/"Rain" single, not originally on any album. Also the "Penny Lane"/"Strawberry Fields" single.
But I absolutely hate Sgt. Pepper, in which I find they focused on the overall concept, not the songs themselves. That it continues to be pronounced "The Best Rock ’n’ Roll Album Of All" bewilders me. I also really dislike Abbey Road, which is probably mystifying to many. What can I say?! Get Back/Let It Be is absolutely unlistenable, just dreadful. Compare it with it's contemporary, The Band's Music From Big Pink. What a contrast! Excellent songs, three great lead singers, the best individual musicians and ensemble playing in Rock 'n' Rock. Just as The Beatles were dying, The Band were there to lead the way forward.
George Harrison is one of my favorite guitarists, but his love of the damn sitar ruined him as a player. Terrible singer, though. Ringo’s playing---originally very cool---took the same course as did that of Keith Moon: he got sluggish as got older (and started drinking heavily), dragging down the feel of the band. Paul’s a great bassist and good songwriter, and an okay singer. John was a good rhythm guitarist (a dead art), but a not-so-good songwriter, as became obvious when he was left to his own devices (including his songs on the later Beatles albums, after Paul and he had stopped collorating). All in my opinion, of course.
But The Beatles boxset needs to be owned just as a "Soundtrack Of Our Lives" documentary, and because of their importance in Rock ’n’ Roll history, not to mention their cultural impact. I think that importance and impact has led many to be a little too uncritical of their music, viewing it and them as a Sacred Cow, above any and all criticism.
