2. speakers
  3. 1301245909

Endless debate: monitor + sub vs floorstanding

Have made a simple system with Peachtree Inova and Proac Sig 8 Tablettes on sand filled stands. Lovely sound I am quite pleased with though I'm considering either supplementing my beloved Tablettes with a sub bass (most likely the new Rel T5) OR grabbing a pair of full range floorstanders (likely used Proac as well).

Any thoughts on the relative merits of the two setups in terms of expression, detail, dynamic spectrum, musicality and also flexibility? Intuitively, it seems I may have more opportunities to play with and fine-tune the experience using Tabletttes plus sub.

I realize there is probably no perfect answer here. Unfortunately, my opportunities for a good side by side listening comparison of the two systems is pretty much nil.
marburg
marburg OP
14 posts
 
All very helpful comments. Many thanks. The damn Rel went up by 100 bucks, but I still think I'll grab one.
ryder
1,689 posts
 
It depends on what you are trying to achieve and the size of your room. If your room or listening area is small then sub is the way to go. It will reinforce that low frequencies and give more body and weight to the overall presentation. A caveat -blending the sub to the mains is a tricky one as poor or incorrect setting up will often cause *unwanted* bass to stick out like a sore thumb.

If the room or listening area is large you will still get an improvement if adding a sub to the main speakers. However, you won't get the scale and a large sound with the diminutive Tablette Ref 8 Sigs. That is where floorstanders with larger drivers come into play.

Good luck bidding on the REL sub.
ryder
1,689 posts
 
[quote]03-27-11: Buconero117
monitor + sub is the way to go. I have proac 1SC's used with dual subs (a Jim Smith must). Great sound. I also have Proac 140's, floor standers. I give the edge to the 1SC's + subs, which have more focused presentations and yet the subs add the missing bottom. [/quote]

The 140 floorstanders have inferior drivers compared to the 1SCs. A properly implemented high quality monitor+sub setup is always more desirable than an inferior pair of floorstanders.
ryder
1,689 posts
 
03-27-11: Buconero117
monitor + sub is the way to go. I have proac 1SC's used with dual subs (a Jim Smith must). Great sound. I also have Proac 140's, floor standers. I give the edge to the 1SC's + subs, which have more focused presentations and yet the subs add the missing bottom.

The 140 floorstanders have inferior drivers compared to the 1SCs. A properly implemented high quality monitor+sub setup is always more desirable than an inferior pair of floorstanders.
marburg OP
14 posts
 


ok..if I'm not beating an already debilitated horse here...

I found to my surprise, a local Proac dealer who adamantly insisted that "most people can't set up 2 speakers properly let alone three. A floorstanding speaker like the D18 will completely demolish any monitor + sub arrangement. "

Any thoughts on that? Is this at all accurate or is the guy another hardened criminal?
More to discover