Is One Subwoofer Really Not Appropriate For 2-Chnl

Is this a case where one good sub is better than two less costly subs?

just a thought...

For me, I'd opt for a higher quality sub versus two less costly ones, but that's just my opinion. For example, I'm a Velodyne dealer and to have two Optimum series subs or one DD Plus series sub would be an easy choice for me. I'd go with the Velodyne DD Plus single sub in a heartbeat. The Optimum series is good, but the Digital Drive Plus is in a whole other league. I use a DD-10 Plus and, honestly, two Optimum 10 would not play as deep and the sound quality are in different leagues as you can guess by the price difference. Two Optimum 10 subs would also cost more than a single DD-10 Plus. The original poster is looking at using very high quality standmounted speakers, so in that situation, two lesser quality subs may stand out more than a higher quality sub which would match the quality of the speakers better. Once again, just my 2 cents.

Hi Bryon, great post! I have a practical question. As I mentioned above, I don't have a lot of placement options for my sub. So, my sub is aimed directly at my seating position and sits about 4-5 inches behind the mains.

In addition, I summed the channels into mono for the sub, so I don't think I can reverse polarity as you suggested, or perhaps I still don't understand how the method works. Having said that, my sub has a built in phase adjustment capability which I adjust to achieve the loudest bass when playing music that puts out a lot of bass. The thought is that I am trying to reduce phase cancellation at the crossover point.

Anything else I can do to improve the bass with my sub?? Thanks.

Bifwynne - Glad my post was helpful to you. If you can manage it, it would be worth the experiment to move the sub roughly coplanar with the mains and see if it improves the system's transient response. It will be audible as better coherence and PRaT.

The fact that you sum the channels into a mono signal for the sub doesn't affect anything in the procedure I described in my last post. If your sub has a polarity switch, use it. If it doesn't, just reverse the positive and negative leads on your speaker wire for *both* of the mains. Then the mains and the sub will have opposite polarity, assuming that your sub doesn't invert polarity.

Adjusting the sub's phase can be helpful, but not nearly as helpful, IME, as time aligning the sub. As I mentioned in my last post, if the sub is behind the mains, the signal that needs to be delayed is *the mains*. Adjusting the sub's phase will do nothing for that. If you cannot digitally delay the mains, you can time align the system by placing the sub coplanar with the mains, or possibly a little in front of them (to compensate for the potential latency - i.e. delay - introduced by the sub itself).

To sum up, if you can do it, move the sub so that it's roughly coplanar with one of the mains, then follow the procedure in my last post. That should get you pretty close to time aligned. IME, the results of sub time alignment are dramatic, especially when the sub is "fast" enough to keep up with the mains.

Bryon

One can work fine. I use a 10" NHT sub with my NHT Classic 3 speakers and the sound is very detailed and smooth.