I read this comment all the time on forums but not one customer has ever said, “Great work! But it sounds different than it did before and I wish I bought a new one instead.” That has happened exactly zero times. Quite the opposite. People are very very happy to have their cartridge back.
People often know nothing about cartridges, turntables, tonearms ... etc.
Most comments are irrelevant and can’t be used as evidence that re-tipping or rebuild with different materials are any better (if the original cartridge wasn’t entry level model like those 103 that are so easy to upgrade). People suffering when their only cartridge is broken and they want to get it back to life quickly, that’s it, they are happy once it’s back to their tonearm and they can continue to enjoy their music. Most of them are even more happy when they can pay less than retail price of a brand new cartridge. But they are not an experts, they are average users of analog systems. Reading comments from such people when they are raving about retipping/rebuild you’re quickly realize that it might be their 5th cartridge in entire life (or probably first MC). Those comments are useless for those who really understand what is a good cartridge and why certain original cartridge is so special.