@co93 - Thanks for the quick response! Yes, that makes a lot of sense. I'm 95% sure I'm getting the Rega P6 at this point. A lot of really great recommendations in this thread but I ultimately think the Rega is going to be best for my use case. The other 5% of me is thinking about a step up to a P8, but I will not likely do that for several reasons, including that I have a toddler and am pretty sure I need a dust cover that fully closes for the safety of the table.
I'm still not quite sure what to do on phonostage. The KC Vibe mk ii is still the top contender, as I've not seen a single bad comment about Sutherland from anyone, and in the $1000 category I'm not sure whether it is worth overthinking this. But I am intrigued by a tube phono pre since it seems like almost all of you prefer that route. Maybe that will be for another day though.
I'm still not quite sure what to do on phonostage. The KC Vibe mk ii is still the top contender, as I've not seen a single bad comment about Sutherland from anyone, and in the $1000 category I'm not sure whether it is worth overthinking this. But I am intrigued by a tube phono pre since it seems like almost all of you prefer that route. Maybe that will be for another day though.