Mike --
Sometimes, I’ve had a performance of something, and I thought it was fine, then a different interpretation made me sit up in my chair. A mediocre performance just doesn’t get the work across the same way. Most classical works have dozens -- important works have hundreds -- of performances to choose from.
In buying "complete works of," you are likely to get a big pudding with a few plums in it. Not my favorite way to know the music. One CD with music you love is better than 10 you tolerate.
Any two recordings will have different perspectives, different halls, different miking, thus different sound worlds. I haven’t mentioned the interpretation yet! Which appeals more to *you*?
I have > 20 version of the Goldberg Variations (of JS Bach), because I enjoy them & wanted to experience other ways they can be played. Now that I have Qobuz, I still listen to other performances but am unlikely to buy more.
So I’d go slowly, find which reviewers seem to agree with your tastes, and try to hear at least samples before you buy.
Sometimes, I’ve had a performance of something, and I thought it was fine, then a different interpretation made me sit up in my chair. A mediocre performance just doesn’t get the work across the same way. Most classical works have dozens -- important works have hundreds -- of performances to choose from.
In buying "complete works of," you are likely to get a big pudding with a few plums in it. Not my favorite way to know the music. One CD with music you love is better than 10 you tolerate.
Any two recordings will have different perspectives, different halls, different miking, thus different sound worlds. I haven’t mentioned the interpretation yet! Which appeals more to *you*?
I have > 20 version of the Goldberg Variations (of JS Bach), because I enjoy them & wanted to experience other ways they can be played. Now that I have Qobuz, I still listen to other performances but am unlikely to buy more.
So I’d go slowly, find which reviewers seem to agree with your tastes, and try to hear at least samples before you buy.