@ghosthouse I see on the last page you and keegiam were discussing guitar players specifically Al De Meola and Allan Holdsworth.
I agree both are extremely talented virtuoso’s on the guitar but they often do get bogged down creating and improvising.
With Allan Holdsworth it was the "gimicky" stuff he tinkered with that annoyed me. Especially that Synthaxe instrument. Allan is one of those players who made some really good albums and some really crappy albums.
Al De Meola, to me, is a little more consistent and not nearly as experimental as Allan was. I like most of his albums but there are a few duds.
Soloing
There are 4 guitar payers right off the top of my head that can play extended improvised solo’s (7 minutes or more) that never "get stuck in neutral" during the solo.
Jimi Hendrix
Jeff Beck
Terry Kath
Duane Allman
All 4 of the above I can listen to their songs and the solo's within them and never get "fatigued"
Jimi was simply the best at this. That he release only 3 "official" studio albums and his estate still reals in millions of dollars in revenue every year is a testament to this. I have the 6 CD set "WINTER LAND LIVE" Jimi played 2 sets per night for 3 nights using the same song list and not one version sounds the same. I have over 50 Hendrix discs in my collection which shows just how much material this genius had written before his untimely death and was on tour playing 300 nights per year for close to 4 years creating all the live albums which were recorded (thankfully) and released over the last 50 years since his death. He also recorded Too many songs in studio to list that were later released.
Jimi's 3 studio albums have not one bad track on any of them. In fact all the songs I would rate 8 - 10 stars out of 10. Listen to the simple solo bridge in "The Wind Cries Mary" and you can hear his excellence in incorporating the same rythm chords into the lead.
(5) Jimi Hendrix - The Wind Cries Mary - YouTubeJimi jams with HOF Jazz organist Larry Young:
(5) Young/Hendrix Jam - YouTube
I will speak about Beck, Kath and Allman later when I have time.