@limomangus That’s both interesting and disheartening, as it’s be a lot easier (and cheaper!) if you could just run the numbers and figure out what would work. Then again, I suppose that’s the fun part of this hobby, eh? :-). I’m definitely learning that there are a zillion variables, and that I can’t address all of them at once. But that’s why it’s helpful to get this kind of input - so thanks!
Need speaker suggestions for my evolving system!
Fair warning: I'm a total newb - on this site & with audio gear - with a pretty decent (to me) budget and pretty tough WAF standards to meet.
My use case:
- Building a system for both music & tv/movies
- Living room is 17'w x 15'd, with 12' vaulted ceilings.
- Speakers on the 17' wall, facing a wall of windows
- The right side of the room (when looking at the speakers) opens to the dining room & kitchen. So a pretty big space.
- Want speakers that can fill the room & rock out (my 9yr old likes impromptu dance parties), but also play well at low volumes, since that's when a lot of my listening happens.
My journey, to date:
- Bought a used pair of Zu Dirty Weekends and LOVED them. Full sound, super clear to me (coming from a soundbar, that's probably not saying much!), loads of bass even without a sub, and they could CRANK!
- Bought a used Marantz NR-1603 50wpc AV receiver to drive them. Worked great!
- Wife was not at all happy with the DW's look (that 10" driver was a bit of a surprise), size (12" x 12" x "38), or color (deep, reddish Maple Sangria). No matter how good they sounded, it was tough to get buy-in on them.
- Same hifi shop got a pair of used Totem Arros in cherry, which were a much better match in size & color. I tried them out, and they sounded amazing at low-to-moderate volumes, especially with acoustic and vocal music. I decided to keep them & sell the DWs.
- I love the Totem sound, and am still stunned by how clearly they create that broad soundstage! It's like magic.
- But...they really struggle to fill the room - and don't seem to handle rock music very well, to my ears.
- Thinking that the Marantz was the issue, since it isn't rated for 4 ohm speakers, I splurged on a used Peachtree nova220se, which drives 350wpc at 4 ohm. I figured that'd give them the boost they need. I was wrong.
- With the Peachtree, low-volume listening is a bit fuller & clearer, which is great. But I think the Arros just aren't made for rocking out - or at least not in a big room. Perhaps their size & my basic understanding of physics should have made that connection.
So now I'm looking for suggestions on what I should consider, as replacements for the Totems, using the following criteria:
- Wood (maple, cherry) finish
- Small (< 38" tall, < 12" wide) form factor
- Capable of filling a room
- Similar imaging & clarity as the Totems (don't have much experience with other speakers)
- Priced ~$3k
There are some used Totem Forest Signatures I've had my eye on, and I saw that Zu is having a sale on their Soul Supremes ($3,700) which I might be able to make a case for. But I haven't heard either.
Curious to hear what other speakers I should consider!
Thanks for the help!
My use case:
- Building a system for both music & tv/movies
- Living room is 17'w x 15'd, with 12' vaulted ceilings.
- Speakers on the 17' wall, facing a wall of windows
- The right side of the room (when looking at the speakers) opens to the dining room & kitchen. So a pretty big space.
- Want speakers that can fill the room & rock out (my 9yr old likes impromptu dance parties), but also play well at low volumes, since that's when a lot of my listening happens.
My journey, to date:
- Bought a used pair of Zu Dirty Weekends and LOVED them. Full sound, super clear to me (coming from a soundbar, that's probably not saying much!), loads of bass even without a sub, and they could CRANK!
- Bought a used Marantz NR-1603 50wpc AV receiver to drive them. Worked great!
- Wife was not at all happy with the DW's look (that 10" driver was a bit of a surprise), size (12" x 12" x "38), or color (deep, reddish Maple Sangria). No matter how good they sounded, it was tough to get buy-in on them.
- Same hifi shop got a pair of used Totem Arros in cherry, which were a much better match in size & color. I tried them out, and they sounded amazing at low-to-moderate volumes, especially with acoustic and vocal music. I decided to keep them & sell the DWs.
- I love the Totem sound, and am still stunned by how clearly they create that broad soundstage! It's like magic.
- But...they really struggle to fill the room - and don't seem to handle rock music very well, to my ears.
- Thinking that the Marantz was the issue, since it isn't rated for 4 ohm speakers, I splurged on a used Peachtree nova220se, which drives 350wpc at 4 ohm. I figured that'd give them the boost they need. I was wrong.
- With the Peachtree, low-volume listening is a bit fuller & clearer, which is great. But I think the Arros just aren't made for rocking out - or at least not in a big room. Perhaps their size & my basic understanding of physics should have made that connection.
So now I'm looking for suggestions on what I should consider, as replacements for the Totems, using the following criteria:
- Wood (maple, cherry) finish
- Small (< 38" tall, < 12" wide) form factor
- Capable of filling a room
- Similar imaging & clarity as the Totems (don't have much experience with other speakers)
- Priced ~$3k
There are some used Totem Forest Signatures I've had my eye on, and I saw that Zu is having a sale on their Soul Supremes ($3,700) which I might be able to make a case for. But I haven't heard either.
Curious to hear what other speakers I should consider!
Thanks for the help!
- ...
- 19 posts total
- 19 posts total