How much “suspension of disbelief do you need?”


We (or most of us) believe that it’s very difficult if not impossible to hear an exact representation of the the sound of a live performance on a recording.
The question is how much do you have to delude yourself into thinking it’s the real thing your listening to, to satisfy yourself.
To some it has to to be as close as possible. But others can make allowances for defects in the sound in order to enjoy the presentation.

‘How much do you need?

 

128x128rvpiano

A longtime friend plays in a world wide band.( 40 yrs) When I get my tickets and passed ,he has us seated in front of the mixing board. Great sound!  If your system images up as well out,( Not Atmos) try Grand Funks " Caught in the Act" for a good live recording. Unspoken ,play it loud! This isn't the band he's in.

OP,

Unless your listening room is at least 50’ wide and deep, you will never correctly hear an orchestra.  The math alone gives me a headache. 
Right now I’m listening to Wayne Shorter, Piano, bass and drums. I can reach out and touch the bass, but with this particular mix, the drums and piano fill every bit of space. And that’s with only three instruments, not the appropriately one hundred in an orchestra.

Apples or oranges. Of more like apples or apple pie.

An electronic recreation of a live event, no matter how advanced, can only be that: an electronic recreation.

Sure, when good electronics, one can think of a live event but it will never be the same.

The humanness of a live performance is a “human experience”. To see, hear and relate to a real person is very different no matter what the acoustics.

To interact with a “machine” can never compare to live.

@tomic601 

 

. What are the SOTA upgrades ?

  • spindle and bearing.
  • roadrunner motor controller
  • And an LPS of sorts. (240v stroll in work)


Ask me how I know?

At present, I'm more or less happy with my personal Audio Illusion Means. *S*

That doesn't mean I don't 'tweak' in some fashion but tends towards level adjusts and hz minutia....

The bulk of the time is spent in enjoyment.  Which has always been the point. ;)

Happy 1-23, J

 

I'm tired of not being a 'bot

I wish I was the major....